Home/Insights/Why Well-Run Clinics Still Overpay Vendors
Practice EconomicsCura Insight
Why Well-Run Independent Veterinary Clinics Still Overpay Vendors
Vendor economics evolve continuously, while most clinics review them only periodically. That mismatch allows otherwise sound arrangements to become commercially outdated.
Brian Fosselman, Founder, Cura Veterinary PartnersAugust 4, 202611-minute read
One of the most reasonable responses an independent veterinary clinic owner can have to a discussion about vendor costs is straightforward: We run a tight operation. The clinic has capable managers, expenses are monitored, inventory is controlled, vendor representatives are known personally, and major purchasing decisions receive appropriate scrutiny.
Those characteristics may accurately describe a well-run practice. They do not, however, establish that every recurring vendor arrangement remains commercially competitive. Running the clinic effectively and continuously benchmarking vendor economics require different systems, information, and management capacity.
A practice can maintain strong discipline in patient care, staffing, scheduling, inventory, and financial reporting without having a dedicated process for consolidating vendor data, tracking notice deadlines, reconciling program economics, testing the market, and confirming that negotiated terms appear correctly on future invoices. In most independent clinics, those activities are distributed among owners, practice managers, inventory leaders, bookkeepers, and other employees whose primary responsibilities lie elsewhere.
Vendor arrangements also continue to evolve after they are selected. Prices change, fees accumulate, usage patterns shift, programs are revised, and new alternatives enter the market. An agreement that was sensible when it began may still function well today while no longer providing the strongest overall result.
That is how avoidable overpayment often develops inside successful practices. It generally reflects the gradual aging of commercial decisions rather than careless management.
What clinic owners should know
Operational discipline does not automatically create vendor-market visibility. A clinic may understand its internal operations extremely well while having limited information about current external pricing, program structures, and alternatives.
Vendor economics change more frequently than most clinics can review them. Rates, fees, rebates, service requirements, usage, and available options continue to evolve between formal evaluations.
Overpayment rarely appears as one obvious mistake. It is more likely to accumulate through modest price increases, missed credits, unnecessary services, outdated commitments, and terms that no longer fit the clinic.
Responsibility is often distributed across several people. The employee who uses a service, the manager who works with the representative, the bookkeeper who records the expense, and the owner who approves the contract may each see only part of the relationship.
A dependable vendor can still have outdated commercial terms. Service quality and pricing competitiveness are separate questions, although both should influence the clinic's final decision.
A credible review should confirm some existing arrangements. The objective is to identify where action is justified and where the incumbent already provides the best combination of economics, service, and operational fit.
Industry context: veterinary owners have limited management capacity
The AVMA's 2025 Economic State of the Veterinary Profession report illustrates how heavily practice owners remain involved in clinical delivery. Among companion-animal-exclusive practices represented in its 2024 Veterinary Practice Owners Survey, owners reported spending an average of 73.8% of their time seeing clients and patients, compared with 22.5% managing operations and 3.3% attending to other tasks. Across the practice types studied, owners spent more than 65% of their time with clients and patients.
The report's practice analysis included 524 practices after applying its inclusion criteria, and 93.9% of those practices were independently owned. These findings describe the analyzed survey sample rather than the entire U.S. veterinary-practice market, but they provide useful context for the competing demands placed on independent owners.
73.8%
Average share of companion-animal-exclusive owner time spent with clients and patients
22.5%
Average share spent managing operations
93.9%
Share of practices in the analyzed survey sample that were independently owned
Source: AVMA, Economic State of the Veterinary Profession 2025, based on the 2024 Veterinary Practice Owners Survey. The practice analysis included 524 practices after the report's inclusion criteria were applied. Findings describe the analyzed survey sample rather than the entire U.S. veterinary-practice population.
The distinction that matters: operating the clinic and governing vendor economics
Well-run clinics typically have strong operating controls. They monitor staffing and scheduling, respond to service problems, maintain inventory discipline, review financial performance, and evaluate major purchases with care. Those activities support clinical reliability, employee effectiveness, and financial stability.
Vendor-market discipline adds another layer of governance. It requires the clinic to maintain complete agreement records, understand notice and renewal dates, reconstruct the true annual cost of major relationships, separate usage changes from pricing changes, reconcile fees and rebates, and compare current terms with credible alternatives.
The clinic must also be able to standardize proposals that use different assumptions, evaluate implementation demands, and verify that revised economics are eventually reflected in actual spending. These activities require detailed information and sustained attention that may not be available through routine operating and accounting processes.
Most independent practices do not employ someone whose primary responsibility is to perform this work across every major expense category. Instead, the responsibilities are absorbed by employees who already manage patient care, people, inventory, financial administration, or daily operations. That arrangement is understandable, but it leaves predictable gaps through which commercial drift can develop.
How vendor costs drift in a well-run clinic
The process usually begins with a sound decision. A clinic identifies a need, evaluates the available options, selects a vendor, and builds the service into its operating model. As employees learn the process and the provider demonstrates reliability, the relationship becomes familiar and less likely to attract management attention.
Familiarity creates genuine operational value. The team knows whom to contact, the service is incorporated into established workflows, and the risks associated with a transition remain avoided. At the same time, the clinic's needs and the vendor's commercial structure continue to evolve.
The original decision may therefore remain embedded in operations long after some of the assumptions behind it have changed.
Exhibit 1
How vendor costs drift in a well-run clinic
A vendor relationship can remain operationally successful after its commercial position has changed.
1
Sound vendor decision
A provider is selected for sound economic and operational reasons.
2
Service becomes embedded
The team learns the process and the relationship becomes familiar.
3
Economics and needs evolve
Pricing, usage, programs, and clinic requirements change.
4
Renewal competes for attention
The decision arrives amid more urgent operating priorities.
5
Review is deferred or narrowed
The prior arrangement is assessed without a current external benchmark.
6
The arrangement may become outdated
Service remains acceptable, but the economics may no longer be strongest.
1
Sound vendor decision
A provider is selected for sound economic and operational reasons.
2
Service becomes embedded
The team learns the process and the relationship becomes familiar.
3
Economics and needs evolve
Pricing, usage, programs, and clinic requirements change.
4
Renewal competes for attention
The decision arrives amid more urgent operating priorities.
5
Review is deferred or narrowed
The prior arrangement is assessed without a current external benchmark.
6
The arrangement may become outdated
Service remains acceptable, but the economics may no longer be strongest.
Source: Cura Veterinary Partners.
The original decision remains fixed while the context changes
Vendor selections reflect the clinic's circumstances and the information available at a particular point in time. The practice may have had fewer doctors, lower purchasing volume, different service requirements, another ownership structure, or a smaller technology footprint when the arrangement began.
As the clinic evolves, a pricing tier that once matched its activity may no longer fit. A service package that was appropriately sized at implementation may include unused capacity, while newer requirements may have been addressed through separate services that create duplication elsewhere.
Conditions on the vendor side change as well. Programs are redesigned, product lists are updated, technology improves, and competitors introduce alternatives that did not exist during the original evaluation. Commercial priorities can shift even when the vendor's service remains reliable.
The clinic does not need to have made a poor decision for the arrangement to become less favorable. Changes in the surrounding context can eventually produce a different answer.
Vendor economics usually change in layers
Commercial drift can be difficult to recognize because it seldom arrives as a single dramatic increase. A base price may rise modestly, a separate fee may be introduced, or a discount may remain unchanged while the clinic's purchasing mix shifts toward items outside the most favorable portion of the program.
Similar effects occur when rebate thresholds become harder to achieve, promotional credits expire, or additional users, equipment, locations, and services are added over several years. Each adjustment may appear manageable when viewed individually.
The combined effect becomes visible only when the clinic reconstructs the relationship across a meaningful period and distinguishes changes in price from changes in volume, utilization, and scope. A recent invoice may be entirely accurate under the current arrangement while offering little insight into whether that arrangement still serves the clinic well.
Responsibility is fragmented across the practice
Recurring vendor spend often has several owners, depending on how ownership is defined. A veterinarian may determine the clinical requirements, an inventory manager may select products and place orders, and a practice manager may manage the relationship and resolve service concerns. The bookkeeper sees the recorded expense, while the owner may approve the initial commitment or a major renewal.
Each person may perform that role effectively, yet no individual necessarily holds a complete view of what the clinic purchases, what it pays in total, how pricing is calculated, which commitments apply, or whether expected benefits have been received. Information about renewal timing and realistic alternatives may be held separately, if it has been assembled at all.
The facts required for a commercial decision are therefore dispersed among people, invoices, contracts, vendor portals, email correspondence, and institutional memory. Operational ownership is present, but complete economic ownership may remain unclear.
Vendor changes are continuous; clinic reviews are episodic
The timing mismatch between vendor activity and internal review is one of the primary reasons cost drift survives. Pricing adjustments, usage changes, service additions, rebate performance, and new market alternatives can occur throughout the life of an agreement.
Internal reviews usually take place at discrete moments, such as budget preparation, contract renewal, a visible service problem, a large price increase, or a management initiative. Depending on the category and the demands facing the practice, those moments may be separated by months or years.
A clinic can therefore conduct a thoughtful review each time one occurs and still miss the cumulative effect of smaller changes between review periods. As the relationship continues, the service may remain familiar while the clinic's understanding of its commercial position becomes progressively less current.
Exhibit 2
The vendor-review timing gap
A review process can be competent each time it occurs and still be too intermittent to detect cumulative drift.
Vendor economics change continuously
Pricing and fees
Usage and service scope
Programs and incentives
Market and clinic requirements
EarlierLater
Internal review occurs periodically
Budget cycle
Contract renewal
Visible problem or price increase
Ownership or management initiative
Outside review
Changes can accumulate between formal review points
Vendor economics change continuously
Pricing and fees
Usage and service scope
Programs and incentives
Market and clinic requirements
Changes can accumulate between formal review points
Internal review occurs periodically
Budget cycle
Contract renewal
Visible problem or price increase
Ownership or management initiative
Outside review
This is a conceptual timing framework and is not drawn to a fixed calendar scale.
Source: Cura Veterinary Partners.
Renewal timing favors continuity
Renewal decisions rarely arrive when the clinic has excess management capacity. A notice deadline may fall during a busy season, a staffing transition, a facility issue, a software implementation, or an ownership discussion.
The agreement may also require action well before its stated expiration date. When the review begins late, there may be insufficient time to gather data, clarify the clinic's requirements, obtain credible alternatives, negotiate with the incumbent, and prepare for a responsible implementation.
The existing provider begins from a position of strength because the service is already installed, employees understand it, and the vendor knows the practice. Historical information may be stored within the system, equipment may be tied to the relationship, and continuing generally requires less immediate work than evaluating a change.
That continuity has legitimate economic and operational value. A sound review should recognize it while also determining whether the premium associated with remaining in place is reasonable.
Internal comparisons do not provide an external benchmark
Clinics often compare a proposed price with the current price, the prior year's expense, or the amount included in the budget. These are useful internal reference points, but each answers a narrower question than whether the arrangement remains competitive.
A smaller increase than originally proposed may represent a successful negotiation without establishing that the resulting price is strong. Spending below budget can indicate effective control even when particular rates remain above realistic alternatives. Stable spending may appear reassuring while the supplier market or available technology has changed substantially.
Accurate financial information therefore does not always provide sufficient market visibility. A clinic may know exactly how much it spent without knowing whether another structure could deliver the same or better operational result at a lower overall cost.
Reliable external benchmarking is also more difficult than comparing two headline rates. Pricing may depend on geography, purchasing volume, product mix, equipment, integrations, service scope, contract length, and participation in particular programs. A useful comparison must account for what the clinic is actually purchasing and the conditions attached to each offer.
A relationship that performs adequately does not create the same urgency as a visible operational problem. When a system works, a distributor delivers reliably, or a laboratory meets the clinic's clinical needs, the team has a reasonable basis for protecting continuity.
A potential transition may involve data migration, employee training, equipment replacement, workflow redesign, ordering changes, contract termination, or temporary disruption. Even evaluating a change consumes management attention before the clinic knows whether the resulting opportunity will justify the effort.
These considerations appropriately raise the threshold for action. A proposed improvement should be material and credible enough to outweigh implementation demands, employee burden, and service risk.
Commercial drift becomes harder to detect when implementation concerns prevent the clinic from evaluating the underlying economics. In that situation, continuity becomes the default without a current understanding of how much the clinic is paying for it or whether that premium remains proportionate to its value.
Why familiar management controls may not detect commercial drift
A well-run clinic may already rely on budgets, financial statements, accountants, buying-group programs, inventory controls, and established relationships with vendor representatives. These mechanisms remain valuable, although each addresses a different portion of the decision.
Financial statements
Financial reporting can reveal total expense and changes over time. It may not show whether a variance resulted from volume, unit pricing, service additions, fees, or contractual terms, particularly when several components are aggregated within one expense account.
Budgets
A budget establishes an internal expectation and helps management allocate resources. It does not independently establish whether the expected amount reflects the strongest currently available commercial position.
Accountants and bookkeepers
Accounting professionals support accurate records, compliance, reporting, and financial analysis. Detailed supplier pricing, contract review, and market benchmarking may fall outside the scope of their engagement.
Buying groups and purchasing programs
A purchasing program may provide meaningful access to discounts, rebates, or supplier terms. The clinic must still determine how much of its actual spend is covered, whether the program matches its purchasing behavior, and whether expected benefits are being fully realized.
Vendor representatives
Strong representatives can provide continuity, product expertise, and timely problem resolution. They also represent the commercial interests and available programs of their own organizations rather than serving as independent market benchmarks.
These controls are not deficient because they do not perform every function. The remaining gap is the integration of actual spending, contract terms, clinic requirements, implementation considerations, and external options into a single decision process.
Overpayment is often a portfolio of small misalignments
The term overpayment can suggest that a clinic accepted an obviously excessive unit price. More commonly, the economic difference is distributed across a collection of smaller issues that receive limited attention individually.
Those issues may include an untested rate, a rebate the clinic does not consistently earn, an administrative fee that has accumulated over time, or a minimum commitment that no longer matches usage. In other cases, the clinic may be paying for inactive users, unnecessary services, older equipment, limited contract flexibility, or manual work created by a service that appears inexpensive on the invoice.
No single issue necessarily justifies a broad project. Across several material relationships, however, the cumulative effect may become meaningful.
The reverse conclusion is equally possible. A vendor with a higher nominal price may provide faster service, fewer errors, stronger integration, better support, or lower administrative burden. Those benefits can justify the difference, which is why a sound analysis should evaluate the clinic's full commercial and operational position rather than search only for the lowest visible number.
What a disciplined vendor-control system looks like
Commercial discipline is best achieved through proportionate review rather than annual rebidding of every relationship. Repeatedly taking stable categories to market would consume management time, strain productive partnerships, and expose the clinic to implementation risk without ensuring a worthwhile result.
Review effort should instead reflect the financial exposure, complexity, contract timing, and operational importance of each category. A practical vendor-control system can be organized into four related levels.
1. Monitor
Ongoing visibility should apply across recurring vendor relationships. The clinic maintains current contracts and notice dates, tracks material changes in expense, investigates unexpected fees or credits, reconciles important rebates, and removes inactive users or obsolete services.
Monitoring should also capture changes in the clinic itself. New doctors, service lines, locations, technology, or purchasing patterns may alter the economics of a relationship even when the vendor makes no visible change.
2. Diagnose
A more detailed review is appropriate when a material increase, unexplained variance, approaching renewal, or important operational change occurs. The clinic reconstructs the annual cost, separates pricing effects from usage changes, examines the governing terms, and identifies the primary economic drivers.
Diagnosis helps determine whether the issue is limited and correctable within the current arrangement or whether the category warrants external comparison.
3. Test
Market testing should be reserved for financially material relationships where a credible alternative may exist. The clinic defines its operational requirements, obtains comparable proposals or market reference points, and gives the incumbent an opportunity to respond.
The resulting options should be evaluated on consistent assumptions that include service, implementation demands, contract terms, and expected economics. A proposal that appears cheaper because it excludes necessary capabilities does not provide a valid comparison.
4. Verify
After an agreement is negotiated or a change is implemented, actual invoices, fees, credits, rebates, and service performance should be checked against the approved terms. This step distinguishes projected value from improvement the clinic has actually realized.
The next renewal and notice dates should also be recorded so that the relationship returns to ongoing monitoring rather than disappearing from view until another issue arises.
Exhibit 3
A proportionate vendor-review model
Commercial discipline means applying the right level of review to the right relationship at the right time.
1
Monitor
Purpose: Maintain visibility
Activities
Track spend, fees, credits, and usage
Maintain contracts and notice dates
Remove inactive or obsolete services
Applied to: All recurring vendor relationships
2
Diagnose
Purpose: Understand a change
Activities
Separate volume from price
Examine terms and cost drivers
Determine whether the issue is limited or broader
Applied to: Material increases, renewals, or unexplained variances
3
Test
Purpose: Evaluate competitiveness
Activities
Benchmark the current arrangement
Obtain comparable proposals
Negotiate and compare total economics
Applied to: Material categories with credible alternatives
4
Verify
Purpose: Confirm the result
Activities
Review invoices, fees, and credits
Monitor service performance
Measure realized improvement against the baseline
Applied to: Negotiated or newly implemented arrangements
Return to Monitor
After implementation, the relationship returns to ongoing monitoring.
Source: Cura Veterinary Partners.
An illustrative well-run clinic
Consider an established independent companion-animal hospital with a capable practice manager, consistent financial reporting, controlled inventory, and longstanding vendor relationships. The clinic is financially stable, its providers generally perform well, and the owner has no interest in disrupting the team without a compelling reason.
A structured review could still produce several different conclusions.
The reference-laboratory relationship may remain the strongest option after its pricing, turnaround time, equipment support, service coverage, and integration are compared with the available alternatives. No provider change is required, but the clinic clarifies the renewal timeline and documents the economic and operational basis for its decision.
The clinic's primary distributor may also remain in place. Item-level analysis could show that the overall program is valuable while a defined group of frequently purchased products has moved away from the most favorable available pricing. The clinic addresses those products and confirms how the rebate structure applies to its actual purchasing mix.
A payment-processing review might reveal that the clinic's effective cost increased gradually through a combination of markup changes and recurring fees. The incumbent receives an opportunity to revise the arrangement before the clinic determines whether a transition is warranted.
A communications or software review may identify several inactive users or services added during an earlier operating period. Those costs can be removed without replacing the underlying provider or disrupting the team's established workflow.
Another category may reveal a modest theoretical opportunity that would require substantial implementation effort. After considering the likely benefit, service risk, and internal burden, the clinic concludes that no change is justified.
This range of outcomes is what a credible review should produce. Some relationships are confirmed, others are refined, and a limited number may warrant broader action. The findings do not indicate that the clinic had been poorly managed; they demonstrate that vendor arrangements age at different rates and require different levels of maintenance.
Where Cura fits
Cura Veterinary Partners helps independent clinics create the commercial visibility that routine operations do not always provide. The work begins without a presumption that the clinic should replace an incumbent, leave a purchasing program, or choose the lowest nominal proposal.
The objective is to establish a documented basis for determining which arrangements should remain, which can be improved, and which deserve a broader evaluation.
Establish the baseline
Cura consolidates available invoices, statements, purchasing data, contracts, fees, credits, rebates, and renewal terms. The analysis separates changes in price from changes in volume and scope, identifies information gaps, and establishes the clinic's current economic position.
Evaluate the options
Cura examines the current arrangement against the clinic's operational requirements and relevant external alternatives. Depending on the category, the appropriate action may be a focused incumbent negotiation, a limited market check, a formal request for proposal, or confirmation that no further process is warranted.
Proposals are compared using consistent assumptions, including service levels, contractual obligations, implementation needs, and expected financial effect. A lower quoted price is not treated as superior when it omits required capabilities or transfers substantial work to the clinic.
Execute and verify
When the clinic approves a change, Cura supports negotiation, implementation planning, and coordination with the relevant parties. Subsequent invoices, fees, and credits are reviewed against the agreed arrangement so that projected improvements can be distinguished from value actually realized.
The result may be a new provider, revised incumbent terms, a narrower service package, better use of an existing program, or no change. Each can be the right answer when it is supported by the evidence.
Cura's perspective
Being well run is evidence of strong operating discipline. It does not establish that every major vendor relationship has recently been reconstructed, benchmarked, and tested against the clinic's current requirements.
Independent practices face an unavoidable timing and capacity mismatch. Vendor pricing and programs continue to evolve, while the people responsible for the clinic must devote most of their attention to patients, employees, clients, and daily operations. That mismatch can create commercial drift without an obvious management failure or breakdown in service.
The appropriate response is a proportionate review system that preserves dependable relationships, directs attention toward material exposures, and introduces an external reference when the decision warrants one. Constant vendor switching would be disruptive, while continuity without periodic review leaves the clinic without a current basis for evaluating its position.
A clinic does not need to assume that it is overpaying in every category. It should, however, have a documented basis for knowing where its major arrangements remain strong and where they may no longer fit.
Could a structured vendor review create meaningful value for your clinic?
If your clinic's major vendor relationships have evolved without a consolidated review of pricing, fees, contracts, and available alternatives, a brief conversation can help determine whether a deeper analysis is warranted.
Brian Fosselman is the founder of Cura Veterinary Partners. His background includes management consulting work focused on procurement-related cost optimization, strategic negotiations, and business performance improvement. Through Cura, he helps independent veterinary clinics evaluate vendor spend, negotiate stronger agreements, and improve cash flow while limiting additional demands on clinical teams.